A Strategic Business Tool for Mobile Infrastructure
Awangku Hairul Nizam P. H. Ali and Anthony S. Atkins
Faculty of Computing, Engineering and Technology, Staffordshire University
Octagon, Beaconside, Stafford, ST16 9DG, United Kingdom
Abstract. This paper outlines the use of a strategic business tool to assist
decision makers in applying mobile applications in their commercial operations.
Outline examples of mobile business applications in hospitals, retail operations
and customer relationship management are presented to improve quality of
service. The paper also describes examples of wireless technologies in relation
to geographic ranges and the implementation costs of mobile technology into
various business environments. A framework is proposed to assist practitioners
in applying mobile technology to business infrastructure.
1 Introduction
Mobile applications and e-business can offer competitive advantage by creating new
platforms to reach global markets [1]. The e-business services allow business
companies to reduce costs and increase revenue from distribution. Increased online
sales and the use of mobile devices can enhance mobile business activities. Mobile
applications are currently being used in warehousing, Small and Medium Enterprise
(SME) and Customer Relationship Management (CRM) systems that allow tracking
of parcels etc. These types of mobile devices suit the business needs and activities of
the companies concerned. This principle of distribution and transaction can be
adapted for e-government or e-society applications. In these cases information can be
distributed electronically similar to the e-society i2010, which the European
Commission is developing for a European Information Society that promotes growth
and jobs in the nation [2,3]. John Hopkins Hospitals implemented mobile
applications to assists in their medical activities, such as e-prescriptions. This
implementation saves the hospitals $1,000 per day by providing the pharmaceutical
information and the medicine that the patient needs [4]. Addenbrooke’s Hospital, in
Cambridge, England, uses Blackberry mobile devices that link to a central database to
provide access to donor list information relevant to emergency surgery and operations
[5]. Partly as a result of the success gained from 176 kidney and liver transplants, the
hospital has a reputation in the use of modern technology for retrieving quick and
accurate information [6,7]. The use of data retrieval through a mobile device can be
similarly used in warehousing; Wal-Mart stocks can be identified using Radio
Frequency Identification (RFID) tags read from a special mobile RFID reader [8].
Nissan automobiles have a similar approach with CRM activities that allow the
salesperson to answer customer queries on the spot [9].
Hairul Nizam P. H. Ali A. and S. Atkins A. (2007).
A Strategic Business Tool for Mobile Infrastructure.
In Proceedings of the 1st International Joint Workshop on Wireless Ubiquitous Computing, pages 23-32
DOI: 10.5220/0002416800230032
Copyright
c
SciTePress
Web-enabled and standalone databases are two mobile data retrieval technologies.
The Web-enabled architecture involves mobile devices to send and retrieve
information from a centralised database. Mobile devices that are used at John
Hopkin’s Hospital and Wal-Mart are examples of web enabled database applications.
With the standalone database, the data are distributed and stored on the mobile
devices. The database can share the data among mobile devices, but the original data
remain in the mobile device. Examples of this mobile application include survey
collecting mobile devices.
The type of wireless technology, such as Wireless Local Area Network (WLAN),
Wifi, Bluetooth and WiMax, will also affect the type of mobile application that a
company can apply in their business activities. The most popular ones are Bluetooth
and Wi-fi connections as they are simple and less expensive to use. Japanese
Wagamama restaurant chains in the UK [10] apply this type of mobile devices. Wi-fi
applications are more technically diverse as they can support both Personal Digital
Assistants (PDA) and computer laptops. The evolution of mobile technology has
provided new opportunities by extending mobile infrastructure into the business,
which enables the business to gain competitive advantage. Although there are many
strategic tools and techniques available such as Porter’s competitive analysis and
Value Chain [11], strategic tools for mobile applications appear to be limited. This
paper outlines a framework to assess strategic applications of mobile technology and
pertinent infrastructure.
2 Application of Wireless Technology
The recent evolution of mobile technology has been dramatic and is evident from the
range of specifications of mobile phones. In the last five years, the bandwidth of
media content transmission has increased from one to three gigabytes of data to
accommodate a variety of built-in cameras, mp3 players and web browser
capabilities. PDA applications evolved from organisational tools to combine GSM
(Global System for Mobile Communication), GPRS (General Packet Radio Service)
services while incorporating cellular coverage and wireless technology, like Bluetooth
and Wi-fi. In addition the mobile devices allow users to make phone calls and send
messages by Short Messaging Service (SMS), or Multimedia Messaging Services
(MMS). They can also send emails and have access to the web. British Telecom has
recently introduced BT Fusion, as shown in Figure 1, which allows mobile users to
switch their phone calls to Wi-fi allowing Voice over IP (VoIP) communication.
Using VoIP can be less expensive than standard land line calls [12]. When the user’s
mobile phones are close to a hotspot, or a Wi-fi connection, the phones automatically
changes its cellular coverage to Wi-fi connections. Currently, users can make calls
10p/hour on landline, 15p/hour on BT mobile phones, 25p/hour on other networks
and make cheaper calls overseas compared to a normal landline and mobile coverage.
The BT Fusion mobile phone features the ability to change network coverage to a Wi-
fi connection, as the user steps in and out of the Wi-fi zones. Setting up a Wi-fi
access point or WLAN, is uncomplicated but involves purchasing a wireless access
point and a monthly subscription for the internet connection. The wireless access
24
Fig. 1. BT Fusion and BT Wi-fi Phones [13].
point has a simple step-by-step instructions which the user can follow through and
apply the necessary security and internet settings. However, to set up a business
WLAN, such as BT openzone, requires expertise to set up an online payment website
to allow their customers to access to the WLAN or internet connection. Customers
can either pay for a prepaid voucher that allows them temporary access to the internet
or they can register and pay a monthly subscription that allows them full access the
wireless service [13].
The advantage of this wireless technology is that it can provide managers with access
to the wireless devices in their business activities. However, the system needs careful
planning to minimise costs and exclude unnecessary wireless components. Figure 2
depicts some available wireless technologies and the geographic range they can
provide in a business. The location of the wireless access point affects its effective
performance. WiMax provides an option covering a large area with wireless access.
It also supports mobile internet services which can be an advantage for most PDA
users. WiMax can however, be relatively costly to implement. Depending on how
many WiMax features are required at each base station, it costs around £8,000 to
£10,000 per unit [14]. Figure 2 indicates that it can be cost effective to mix Wi-fi and
long range relay components to maximise efficiency and provide appropriate
coverage for various business activities.
25
Fig. 2. Wireless Range Components and Costs.
In some cases the business may be located in geographical areas unsuited to direct
wireless coverage. While Wi-fi components can cover the area of the local
community, the clustered environment of a village and the distance of the nearest
neighbouring village, may limit the Wi-fi range. Wireless relay points can overcome
these obstacles, but the geographical landscape may block the frequency. In these
instances it can be advantages to apply WiMax technology to provide wireless
coverage, such as in Baramati, Calcutta as shown in Figure 3 [15]. The
implementation of WiMax is efficient compared to spreading numerous Wi-fi relay
points around the area. The advent of new 3G technologies and the coming of
WiMax involved around 47,000 base stations in the UK. Moreover two thirds of these
installations are on existing buildings. When WiMax is used in conjunction with Wi-
fi components, it can cause increased radiation exposure including thermal effects.
This radiation is concentrated around wireless installations [16]. For public safety,
base stations and wireless components are at a safe distance from densely populated
areas. Despite this separation, exposure to this radiation can affect some people in the
vicinity [16]. The health and safety issues with regard to implementing this
technology should be assessed to ensure the proposals comply with international
standards [17,18].
26
Fig. 3. Implementation of WiMax Base Station in the City of Baramati, Calcutta [16].
3 Strategic Planning Tool Model
Strategic planning is often used in starting a new product or in improving business
activities in a competitive environment. Managers often use strategic tools for
forward planning, or to propose a new solution to increase business profits. The
planning usually involves identifying weaknesses, or opportunities in the business
environment. The use of strategic management tools can provide insights helpful in
competing against competitors. Some business strategic tools involve applying new
technology, including sharing other business services to decrease costs and increase
profit. Other strategies suggest concentrating on the source of income, such as
ensuring customer satisfaction, or improving relations with the suppliers and buyers.
Some strategic ideas are ineffective because of the inability to predict environmental
changes, coordination, and communication with the suppliers and the customers.
There is a need for strategic tools, providing managers with guidance to assess and
coordinate the business and to provide possible competitive advantage in the business
environment. To find a strategic tool that applies to the specific business tends to be
problematic. Business tools such as the SWOT (Strength, Weaknesses, Opportunities
and Threats) and PEST (Political, Economical, Socio-Cultural and Technological) are
commonly used for marketing and in IT for business strategy. Strategic tools, such as
the Strategic Grid [19], Porter’s Five Forces [11], Value Chain [11], IT Business
Alignment tool [20], can improve business activities and assist in providing
competitive advantage. The proposed Mobile Business Application Framework,
shown in Figure 4, is an aid to business management in decision making within the
three regions of user mobility. The framework consists of two sections, firstly the
Financial Scorecard, as shown in Section A of Figure 4. The Financial Scorecard is
used to assess the business process, activities and financial standing, similar to a cost
WiMax Base
Station
27
Fig. 4. Mobile Business Application Framework – Financial Scorecard (Section A).
28
benefit analysis, and can identify the weaknesses and opportunity of the company
[21]. The Financial Scorecard helps the business to measure performance and resolve
customer relations and strategy issues. Figure 4 illustrates that the financial scorecard
has four types of perspective as shown in Section A: the Financial, Customer,
Learning, and Growth, and Internal Business Process respectively. Each of these
perspectives evaluates the strength and weaknesses of the business by assessing the
previous records of its activities. An example of the use of the scorecard is when a
company is considering implementing a mobile technology to improve the inventory
system using Radio Frequency Identification (RFID) technology. The company could
evaluate the expected benefits by using the process cycle of the Financial Scorecard.
1. In Part 1 of Figure 4, the process cycle of the Financial Scorecard starts with the
Financial Perspective. Management assess Financial Perspective, looking at
previous records or accounts of the business activities, to set objectives, measures
and operational goals. At the end of the business process, the management can
view the record and comment on the Management Initiatives. This feedback
checks if the business has reached their intended goals or requires additional
procedures to enhance their business.
2. These Scorecard procedures are repeated for the Customer, Learning and Growth,
and the Internal Business Perspective.
3. The Internal Business Process uses the Mobile RFID Technology to enhance
stock location processes in the warehouse. The Management Initiatives column
indicated in Part 2 of Figure 4 will be used to record the success factor at the end
of the implementation.
4. As the cycle repeats, the Management Initiatives for the Financial Perspective are
assessed and recorded, to monitor the effects of implementing a mobile
technology in the business. This iterative process is repeated for the Customer,
and the Learning and Growth Perspective.
5. After completing the cycle (anti-clockwise in Part 1 of Figure 4) the Internal
Business Process for implementing the mobile technology is assessed against the
target goals as shown in Part 3.
In Figure 5, Section B illustrates the strategic framework and identifies the type of
mobile device that would be suitable to the business. The framework indicated in Part
1 illustrates a radial wave, or a ripple, which depicts the mobility range for mobile
applications involving the Internet, Extranet, and Intranet (Mobile Application
Region). These three regions are shown on the horizontal axis of the Framework.
Part 2 of Figure 5 shows the implementation of the mobile RFID technology is
contained within the warehouse, consequently this is an Intranet region. In each
region, there are also circular bands of mobile usage. These bands are colour coded to
signify ‘critical data transfer,’ which indicates the importance of data transmission to
the business applications. The three different regions differentiate the types of mobile
device and determine how the software application can be implemented in relation to
business operations. The type of mobile device, or application, used in the business
is shown by the vertical axis of the diagram (Mobile Technology Infrastructure, Part
3). The Intranet and Extranet region of the framework, illustrated in Figure 5, can
apply a fully integrated mobile device or customised application using normal mobile
phones, such as Wal-Mart Wireless Inventory Checking [8]. Also users within the
29
Fig. 5. Mobile Business Application Framework – Mobile Technology Application (Section B).
30
Internet region can use normal mobile devices but they will link or visit a web-
enabled e-commerce database, to connect to an application, for example an SMS
vending machine [22].
4 Conclusion
The strategic framework tool presented here is designed to help managers identify
where mobile technology can enhance their strategic business operations. The
business strategy should align with IT strategy, organisational infrastructure and
information system infrastructure, in order to provide competitive advantage. Popular
types of wireless technology are Wi-fi and Bluetooth technology. These technologies
are effective because of the small wireless range. A short wireless range allows a
more secure system, as the data transmission signal may be contained within the
business area; the Japanese restaurant Wagamama [10] have implemented short range
Bluetooth technology within their business. WiMax, can be normally used to
overcome geographical boundaries, or to avoid the costs of cabling, as it has a greater
geographical range. This paper outlines the applications of the proposed strategic
framework to several mobile commercial applicants. It demonstrates the use of a
Financial Scorecard to evaluate the business cost effectiveness. Departmental goals
within the company can be assessed, allowing managers to identify and align strategic
initiatives to the business [21]. In the case of mobile technology, the strategic
framework assesses the suitability of mobile devices for the business and considers
the type of security and applications appropriate for a particular mobile device. The
proposed mobile strategic framework is designed to assist mangers to make informed
decisions and increase competitive advantage in mobile infrastructure enhancements.
References
1. Farhoomand, A., Ng, S. P.: Creating Sustainable Competitive Advantage Through
Internetworked Communities. In: Communication of the ACM, Vol. 46, No.9 (2003) 83-88
2. Haines, L.: Digital divide is self-repairing, says UK gov (2005) Retrieved 5 February
2007:- http://www.theregister.co.uk/2005/09/06/digital-divide/
3. DTI: i2010 – Responding To The Challenge (2005) Retrieved 5 January 2007:-
http://www.egovmonitor.com/reports/rep12086.pdf
4. Brian, K.: Lowering Health Care Costs Out-of-the-Box (2006) Retrieved 27 September
2006:- http://wireless.sys-con.com/read/40975.htm
5. Kinn, S.: Digital Communications to Replace Ambulance Service Radio, ITIN, Vol. 14,
Issue 1 (2002)
6. Cambridge University Hospitals,: New system helps Addenbrooke’s transplant team deliver
more efficient care (2004) Retrieved 15 January 2005:-
http://www.addenbrookes.org.uk/news/news2004/dec/transplant_device_151204.html
7. Blackberry: Blackberry Case Study Addenbrooke’s Hospital, Cambridge, Health Care
(2006) Retrieved 4 April 2006:-
http://www.blackberry.com/uk/news/pdfs/addenbrookes_casestudy.pdf
31
8. Sliwa, C.: Wal-Mart CEO promises ‘tough love’ approach to RFID use (2004) Retrieved at
5 April 2006:-
http://www.computerworld.com/mobiletopics/mobile/technology/story/0,10801,89011,00.h
tml
9. Greengard, S.: Customer Services Goes Wireless, Business Finance (2001) 35
10. Terry, L.: Serving up Wireless, Wireless Business and Technology (2006) Retrieved 4
April 2006:- http://wbt.sys-con.com/read/40916.htm
11. Porter, M. E.: Strategy and the Internet, Harvard Business Review March (2001) 63-78
12. BT: What is BT Fusion (2006) Retrieved 15 February 2007:-
http://www.btbusinessshop.com/icat/btfusion_whatis
13. BT: BT Openzone (2006) Retrieved 15 February 2007:-
http://www.btbroadbandoffice.com/internetapplications/openzone?com.bea.event.type=link
click&oLName=link.searchresults&oLDesc=KB_761
14. Baines, R.: 3G home base stations turn UMA and convergence from threat to opportunity
for operators (2006) Retrieved 4 January 2007:-
http://www.fiercewireless.com/story/feature-3g-home-base-stations-turn-uma-and-
convergence-from-threat-into-opp/2006-06-23
15. Mahalingam, T.V.: Baramati Goes WiMax, Business Today, 17 December (2006)
16. Alexander, L.: Are Wireless Networks Safe? (2007) Retrieved 15 February 2007:-
http://blogs.cio.com/node/656
17. WHO: Electromagnetic Fields (EMF) Protection (2003) Retrieved 15 February 2007:-
http://www.who.int/docstore/peh-emf/EMFStandards/who-
0102/Europe/United_Kingdom_files/table_uk.htm
18. WHO: Standard and Guidelines (2007) Retrieved 15 February 2007:-
http://www.who.int/peh-emf/standards/en/
19. Shaw, R., Atkins, A. S.: Application of a Customer Relationship Management System for a
Large Independent Travel Agent. In: Proceedings of the IADIS International Conference
WWW/Internet (ICWI), Vol. II (2005) 322-327
20. Henderson, J. C., Venkatramon, N.: Strategic Alignment: Leveraging Information
Technology for Transforming Organisations. In: IBM Systems Journal, Vol. 32, No. 1
(1993) 4-16
21. Lorsch, J.W.: Smelling Smoke: Why Boards of Directors Need the Balanced Scorecard. In:
Balanced Scorecard Report, September-October (1993) 9
22. SAFECOM: Emerging Wireless Technologies 4G Applications and Services (2007)
Retrieved 30 March 2007:- http://www.safecomprogram.gov/NR/rdonlyres/3CBCEA82-
9C05-4CF5-B8E7-DBBA0DC6199E/0/4GApplications_Services.pdf
32