
 
Table 1: Benchmark Data and Proposed Method Results 
for SVM (Sivakumari, Praveena & Amudha 2009). 
 
5 DISCUSSION  
AND CONCLUSIONS 
The aim of the proposed method is revealing the 
patterns in the event data by enabling magnitude 
independent event comparisons according to the 
event rms values, time and duration shifts in order to 
detect type similarities. The current focus on the PQ 
mining is restricted on small parameters and lack of 
cause and effect analysis view. The methods are 
based on just examining limited PQ parameter 
values for a limited time period and describe the 
overall view at that period. By means of the 
proposed method, long period event data 
examination is made possible. The method focuses 
on the magnitude independent patterns in the data by 
combining the appropriate instance-based learning 
algorithm results, expert knowledge and SVM 
modeling. Chunk-based application of the 
algorithms makes system able to handle big amount 
of data, however the chunk-based structure makes 
the methodology not deterministic compared to the 
original versions of the selected clustering and 
classification algorithms. 
 
Although the PQ event data is time series, 
throughout this paper the time component of the 
events are just considered as the occurring time. 
However, a complete analysis of the system should 
reveal the time series based characteristics and 
behavior of the system together with examining the 
spatial characteristics of the system.  
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS 
This research and technology development work is 
carried out as a subproject of the National Power 
Quality Project of Turkey. Authors would like to 
thank the Public Research Support Group 
(KAMAG) of the TÜBİTAK for full financial 
support of the project. 
 
REFERENCES 
A. Asheibi, D. Stirling, D. Soetanto, “Analyzing 
Harmonic Monitoring Data Using Data Mining”, 5th 
Australian Data Mining Conference, AusDM, 2006.  
A. Asheibi, D. Stirling, D. Robinson, “Identification of 
Load Power Quality Characteristics Using Data 
Mining”, IEEE CCECE/CCGEI, 2006. 
Autoclass, viewed 5 March 2010, http://ti.arc.nasa.gov/ 
project/autoclass/.  
B. Biswal, P. K. dash, J. B. V. Reddy, “Power Signal 
Classification Using Dynamic Wavelet Network”, 
Applied Soft Computing, vol. 9, pp. 118-125, 2009. 
G.S. Hu, F.F. Zhu, Z. Ren, “Power quality disturbance 
identification using wavelet packet entropy and 
weighted support vector machines”, Expert Systems 
with Applications, vol. 35, pp. 143-149, 2008. 
M. Wang, G. I. Rowe, A. V. Mamishev, “Classification of 
Power Quality Events Using Optimal Time-Frequency 
Representations – Part 2: Application”,  IEEE Trans. 
on Power Delivery, vol. 19, no. 3, July 2003. 
M. Uyar, S. Yildirim, M. T. Gencoglu, “An expert system 
based on S-transform and neural network for 
automatic classification of power quality 
disturbances”, Expert Systems with Applications, 
Elsevier, 2008. 
Jolliffe, I. T., 2002. Principal Component Analysis. 
Second ed. Springer Series in Statistics. New York: 
Springer-Verlag New York. 
O. N. Gerek, D. G. Ece, A. Barkana, “Covariance 
Analysis of Voltage Waveform Signature for Power-
Quality Event Classification”, IEEE Trans. on Power 
Delivery, vol. 21, no. 4, Oct. 2006. 
P. K. Dash, I. L.W. Chun, M. V. Chilukuri, “Power 
Quality Data Mining Using Soft Computing and 
Wavelet Transform”,  Conference on Convergent 
Technologies for Asia-Pacific Region, TENCON 
2003. 
Snob, viewed 2 March 2010 http:// 
www.datamining.monash.edu.au/software/snob/. 
S. Sivakumari, R. Praveena Priyadarsini, P. Amudha, 
“Performance evaluation of SVM Kernels Using 
Hybrid PSO-SVM”, ICGST-AIML Journal, ISSN: 
1687-4846, Volume 9, Issue I, February 2009. 
Y. Liao, J. B. Lee, “A fuzzy expert system for classifying 
power quality disturbances”, Electrical Power and 
Energy Systems, vol. 26, pp. 199-205, 2004. 
 
INTEGRATED INSTANCE-BASED AND KERNEL METHODS FOR POWER QUALITY KNOWLEDGE MODELING
357