
 
4.4 Frame Dropping 
and Frame Swapping Attack 
Frame dropping and swapping are very simple and 
common attacks because of data redundancy. To 
investigate the robustness of the proposed method 
against these kinds of attacks, extraction of the 
watermark after dropping and swapping different 
rates of frames in the video clips was performed. 
Experimental results are shown in Table.2. 
Table 2: Results after frame dropping and frame Swapping 
attack. 
  1/32 1/16 1/8 1/4 
 
forman 
Dropping  0.9878  0.9745 0.9588 0.9398 
Swapping  0.9912  0.9813 0.9732 0.9532 
 
Stefan 
Dropping  0.9897  0.9867 0.9689 0.9478 
Swapping  0.9932  0.9889 0.9773 0.9529 
 
According to the above experimental results, the 
watermarking scheme is robust against a variety of 
common video processing attacks such as median 
filtering; frame averaging, frame dropping, frame 
swapping and MPEG2 lossy compression. The 
extracted watermark is highly similar to the original 
watermark. 
This method is compared with non-blind method 
(X. Niu, shenghe Sun, 2000) and blind method (A. 
Essaouabi, E. Ibnelhaj, 2009) for Stefan sequences. 
Figure 9.(a) and (b) 
 
 
(a) The effect of the frame dropping 
 
(b) The effect of the frame swapping 
Figure 9: comparison of Blind, Non Blind and proposal 
watermarking scheme for Stefan scene. 
5 CONCLUSIONS 
This paper presented semi-blind video watermarking 
based on wavelet transform. By using the secret key 
in embedding algorithm, this algorithm has high 
security. Image that is used as a watermark is a 
binary image. Procedure of this method includes 
video processing, video embedding and video 
detection that are described in details. This method 
is a powerful method against attacks such as frame 
averaging, frame swapping, frame dropping, median 
filtering and MPEG2 lossy compression. 
REFERENCES 
F. Harung, B. Girod, 1998. watermarking of 
uncompressed and compressed video signal 
processing, 66 (3) pp. 283-301. 
H. Park, S. H. Lee, and Y. S. Moon, 2006. Adaptive video 
watermarking utilizing video characteristics in 3D-
DCT domain. lecture notes in computer science, pp. 
397-406. 
L. Angiang, L. Jing, 2007. A novel scheme for robust 
video watermark in the 3D-DWT domain. first 
international symposium on data, pp. 514-516. 
Z. Huang-yu, L. Ying, W. Cheng-ke, 2004. A Blind 
spatial-temporal algorithm based on 3D wavelet for 
video watermarking. international conference on 
multimedia and Expo (ICME) ,pp 1727-1730. 
K. Yeo, H. J Kim, 2003. Generalized Patchwork 
algorithm for image watermarking. international 
conference on multimedia system, pp 261-265. 
H. Kii, J. Onishi, S. Ozawa, 1999. The Digital 
Watermarking method by using both patchwork and 
DCT. IEEE international conference on multimedia 
system ,pp 895-899. 
OSluciak, R. Vargic, 2004. An Audio Watermarking 
method based on wavelet patchwork algorithm. IEEE 
international conference on multimedia. 
N. Khademi, M. A. Akhaee, S. M. Ahadi, H. 
Amindavar,August 2009. Robust Multiplicative 
Patchwork method for audio watermarking," IEEE 
Transaction on audio, speech and language processing, 
Vol 17, NO.6,pp 1133-1141. 
L. Anqiang, L. Jing, 2007. A Novel Scheme for robust 
video watermarking in 3D-DWT Domain. First 
International symposium on data, privacy and E-
Commerce IEEE ,pp 514-516. 
A. Essaouabi, E. Ibnelhaj, 2009. A 3D wavelet-Based 
method for digital video watermarking. IEEE 
international conference on multimedia, pp 429-434. 
D. Simitopoulos, S. Tsaftaris and N. Boulgouris, Aug. 
2002.compressed-domain video watermarking of 
MPEG stream. in proc. IEEE int. conf. on multimedia 
and Expo, pp. 569-572. 
ROBUST VIDEO WATERMARKING BASED ON 3D-DWT USING PATCHWORK METHOD
113