Figure 8: Equity line of FTS and TS.
As far as the performance indexes are concerned,
a quick comparison is enough to state that FTS is
better than the TS, from every point of view. In fact,
the FTS is stronger (it has a better Win/Lose Index
and a better Buy & Hold Index) and it is also much
more reliable (it has a better Profit/Loss Index and a
better Reward/Risk Index) than the TS.
6 CONCLUSIONS
Designing both the non-fuzzy trading system and the
fuzzy one haven’t any pretension to satisfy real
operative aims. The task of our research has been to
show that we’ve been able to improve results of
some simple and well-known rules of technical
analysis through the application of fuzzy logic
principles.
First, we have observed that an automatic
decisional system, planned as an application for
stock market, has to provide a general model which
we have modified and optimized using our own
knowledge: fuzzy logic, a well known technique of
soft computing. As matter of fact, the “transparent”
structure belonging to a fuzzy logic system allows
easy interactions with the trader, through an
interactive employment, but designing a fuzzy
trading system implies some real difficulties to
choose the right parameters for the fuzzy logic
controller. We have solved this problem using
Genetic Algorithms as an optimization technique.
So the task of our research has been the
implementation of a fuzzy trading system (FTS) as
an alternative to an equivalent non-fuzzy trading
system (TS).
Our results have made us state that not only
fuzzy logic is a valid alternative to the classical
implementation of a trading system, but from every
points of view, it also improves its performances.
REFERENCES
A. Elder, Trading for a Living - Wiley Finance Editions
(1993)
Malkiel B.G., A Random Walk down Wall Street, Dow
Jones Irwin (1981)
Fama, E. and IC. French, Business Conditions and
Expected Stock Returns, Joumal of Financial
Economics, Vol. 25, 1989, pp. 23-50
Edwards R.D. Magee J., Technical Analysis of Stock
Trends, Magee (1957)
Goldman Sack, The International Economic Analyst,
Vol7, Issue No. 1 1,1992
Schwager J.D., Fundamental Analysis, Wiley (1995)
Hartle T., Average Directional Movement Index (ADX),
Stocks & Commodities Vol.9, 1991
G.J. Deboeck, Trading on the edge - Wiley Finance
Editions (1994)
Rong-Jun Li Zhi-Bin Xiong, Forecasting stock market
with fuzzy neural networks,Machine Learning and
Cybernetics, 2005, pp.3475 - 3479 Vol. 6, August
2005
Hiemstra, Y., A stock market forecasting support system
based on fuzzy logic, System Sciences, 1994. Vol.III,
pp.281 - 287, Jan 1994
Setnes, M. van Drempt, O.J.H., Fuzzy modeling in stock-
market analysis, Computational Intelligence for
Financial Engineering, 1999,pp. 250 - 258, March
1999
H.S. Ng, K.P. Lam, S.S. Lam Incremental genetic fuzzy
expert trading system for derivatives market timing",
Computacional Intelligence for Financial Engineering,
2003, pp. 421-427, March 2003.
H. Dourra, P. Siy Investment using technical analysis and
fuzzy logic, Fuzzy sets and systems, 127 (2002), pp.
221-240.
Yager, R. R. and L. A. Zadeh (eds.), An Introdiiction to
Fuzzv Logic Applications in Intelligent Svstems,
Kluwer Academic Publishers, Dordrecht, 1992
Zadeh, L.A. Fuzzy Sets as a Basis for a Theory of
Possibility Fuzzy Sets and Systems 1, 1978
Zadeh L.A., Fuzzy Sets, Information and Control, Vol.8,
June 1965,pp. 338-353
Mamdani,E.H. and Assilian,S., An experiment in linguistic
synthesis with a fuzzy logic controller, Int. J.Man
Mach. Studies, Vol. 7, No. 1, 1975
King,P.J. and Mamdani,E.H., The Application of Fuzzy
Control System to Industrial Process, Automatica,
Vol.13., 1977
Karr,C.L. and Gentry,E.J. Fuzzy Control of pH Using
Genetic Algorithms, IEEE Trans.on Fuzzy Systems,
Vol.1, Feb.1993
Davis, L., Handbook of Genetic Algorithms. NY:Van
Nostrand Reinhold, 1991
Goldberg, D.E.. Genetic Algorithms in Search,
Optimization and Machine Learning. US:Addison -
Wesley, 1989
A NEW FUZZY LOGIC CONTROLLER FOR TRADING ON THE STOCK MARKET
329