measurements fit in the extended model. It also
provided empirical evidence support for the
extended model.
5 DISCUSSION AND SUMMARY
A set of measurements with 10 factors and their
corresponding dimensions was identified in Table 3
based on the literature and the qualitative and
quantitative data gathered from four different e-
commerce website stakeholders. It is the
combination of these factors that measures the
success of an e-commerce website rather than an
individual factor. The survey results suggested that
security, smooth transaction processes and smooth
shopping processes are the most important concerns
for online shoppers. Good protection on confidential
information should help to gain the consumer's trust
(Yazdanifard et al., 2011) and maintain customer
loyalty. The IS success model (DeLone & McLean,
2004) checking suggested that the proposed
measurements are comprehensive; however, they are
not necessarily accurate. The proposed
measurements fit in the extended model (Ghandour
et al., 2008), which also provides empirical evidence
support for this model. To refine the measurements
further, empirical tests involving a set of e-
commerce websites and their customers/owners are
required.
Comparing the proposed measurements with the
existing work, the customized ISO 9126 quality
model (Behkamal et al., 2009) seems the closest.
They both define the quality factors in a hierarchical
structure and assign numerical values to the quality
factors. However, one is for B2B e-commerce
websites and the other is for B2C. In terms of quality
attributes, the customized ISO 9126 quality model
emphasizes the user and development factors, such
as “Functionality”, “Reliability” and “Usability”; the
proposed measurements emphasize the customer
and business-related factors more, such as “Website
Design”, “Website Content”, “Shopping Process”
and “Transaction Process and Volume”. In terms of
process, five steps were defined in the customized
ISO 9126 quality model, particularly in step 4, a
widely-used method, analytical hierarchy process
(AHP) is carefully followed. This systematic
approach makes it easy to generalise the five steps
for other types of e-commerce websites such as
B2C. However, the factors should be revised to
include more customer-related features. On the other
hand, this work used the scores given by the users
and adjusts the quality factors by means of simpe
statistics instruments. These were further improved
by considering the opinions of the other
stakeholders. In terms of data, only users’
viewpoints and developers’ viewpoints were
considered in the customized ISO 9126 quality
model; in the proposed measurements, users’,
developers’, business owners’ and researchers’
viewpoints were considered, therefore, the resulting
quality factors should be more complete.
The small sample size of the online survey
limited the use of rigorous statistics in the data
analysis, instead, a mixed approach using combined
qualitative and quantitative analysis was used on
these data. A large sample with a more general
population should improve the accuracy of the
results.
REFERENCES
Anil, S., Ting, L. T., Moe, L. H. & Jonathan, G. P. G.,
2003. Overcoming barriers to the successful adoption
of electronic commerce in Singapore. International
Journal of Mobile Communications, 1(1-2), pp. 194-
231.
Balfagih, Z., Mohamed, N. & Mahmud, M., 2010. A
Framework for Quality Assurance of Electronic
Commerce Websites. Chapter 9, E-Commerce, Edited
by Kyeong Kang, ISBN 978-953-7619-98-5,
Published by In-tech.
Barnes, S. J., 2002. The electronic commerce value chain:
Analysis and future developments. International
Journal of Information Management, 22(2), pp. 91-
108.
Behkamal, B., Kahani, M., & Akbari, M. K., 2009.
Customizing ISO 9126 quality model for evaluation of
B2B applications. Information and Software
Technology, 51(3), pp. 599-609.
Bezes, C., 2009. E-Commerce Website Evaluation: A
Critical Review. Working Paper.
Blanchard, B. & Fabrycky, W., 1990. Systems engineering
and analysis. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University
Press.
Cao, M., Zhang, Q. & Seydel, J., 2005. B2C e-commerce
web site quality: an empirical examination. Industrial
Management & Data Systems, 105(5), pp. 645-661.
Carney, M., 2005. Trade Me Success Secrets: How to Buy
Better and Sell More Profitably on New Zealand's
Most Popular Auction Site. Buckinghamshire, UK:
Activity Press.
Chen, R., 2005. Modeling of User Acceptance of
Consumer E-Commerce Website. Lecture Notes in
Computer Science, 38(6), pp. 452-462.
Citera, M. & Beauregard, R., 2005. An experimental study
of credibility in e-Negotiations. Psychology and
Marketing, 3(12), pp. 310-332.
DeLone, W. H. & McLean, E. R., 2003. The DeLone and
McLean Model of Information Systems Success, A
AnInvestigationofFactorsandMeasurementsforSuccessfule-CommerceWebsites
359