6 DISCUSSION
The study results indicate that students present
themselves in career networks like Xing in a slightly
idealized way. However, it appears that the Xing
profile page is used for impression management only
to a small extent: The information posted on the
profile pages is more realistic than expected, even
though there are slight differences with respect to
various types of information. Thus, with regard to
this paper’s title, there seems to be only few
‘glittering’.
This could be explained by the fact that Xing is a
career network where students search for potential
employers and want to show presence on the labour
market: Data provided here, like for example work
experience and language levels, will be verified in
future job application processes and false statements
might have negative consequences. Therefore,
idealization would be useful to be selected as a
potential employee, considering that social
networking sites have become an important tool to
find additional information about applicants (Caers
and Castelyns, 2011; Davidson et al., 2011), but in
the next step may result in a negative effect.
The differences regarding various types of
information could be due to Xing’s very objective
evaluation scheme. The strongest idealizations can
be found in areas that provide some space for
interpretation (e.g. language level, competences). On
the other hand, information that is very much
standardized and can be easily verified (e.g. number
of job positions) are not subject to idealization.
Unlike prior studies showing that men and
women try to embody different desired identities in
social networks, we found no relations between
gender and degree of idealization. This might be due
to the fact that former research focused on private
social networks, whereas Xing is a dedicated
business network. More research is needed to
investigate impression management in this field. In
addition the connection between gender and the
amount of other, in this study not considered actions
on XING like posting or messaging should be
considered in further research.
The low but significant correlation between age
and the degree of idealization could be interpreted in
several ways. For instance, the curriculum vitae of
older people will be more detailed, and as a result
there is no need for idealization. In contrast, younger
people use idealization to ‘boost’ their CVs. Other
explanations include a greater proximity to one’s job
entry or maybe a growing confidence in one’s own
professional skills and thus less need for
idealization.
The present study has some limitations. First,
only users from one social network–namely Xing–
where investigated. Furthermore, the study focused
on students, thus limiting the generalizability of the
results to populations with other socio-demographic
characteristics...Second, the results of the study have
to be considered critically in the light of social
desirability. Idealization refers to an issue where a
truthful answer, despite anonymity, could lead to a
negative image. Even though there were no negative
consequences for the participants, admitting
idealization might nevertheless impact their self-
image in a negative way.
The expectation to find strongly pronounced
impression management among Xing users could
not be confirmed. While this is in line with previous
studies of other social networks like Facebook (Back
et al., 2010) where a low degree of idealization was
found as well, it is unclear whether this is due to
characteristics of the sample or the nature of
business networks such as Xing. Therefore, it would
be interesting to investigate whether people who use
business as well as private networks show different
levels of idealization or use different impression
management strategies in the two contexts. From our
findings practical implications for personnel
managers, who use Xing for the recruitment of
young academics, can be drawn. Recruiters can
assume that the information given in the profiles is
basically realistic. Nevertheless, they should be
more cautious with respect to information that
provides more leeway for interpretation, such as
language levels, where more idealization was found.
Finally, we observed a notable imbalance
regarding the presence of different professions–or
fields of study, respectively–within the Xing
network: Students from Economics and related
fields were clearly overrepresented and also used
paid premium accounts more often Possibly,
students from business-related fields tend to use
these kind of networks more often. Recruiters as
well as researchers should keep this in mind.
REFERENCES
Alby T. (2006). Web 2.0: Konzepte, Anwendungen,
Technologien. München: Hanser. S. 89.
Alpizar, K., Islas-Alvarado, R., Warren, C. W., & Fiebert,
M. S. (2012). Gender, Sexuality and Impression
Management on Facebook. International Review of
Social Sciences and Humanities, 4(1), 121-125.
Back, M. D., Stopfer, J. M., Vazire, S., Gaddis, S.,
Schmukle, S. C., Egloff, B., & Gosling, S. D. (2010).
MoreGlitterthanGold?-AnAnalysisofVirtualImpressionManagementBehaviorinOnlineCareer-networks
653