hedging
(Black-
Scholes
model)
Profit
with
hedging
(Cox-
Ross-
Rubinst
ein
model)
0.0149
80
0.0220
62
0.0186
12
0.0153
61
0.011089
0.0138
59
0.01124
11
0.01151
3
0.01151
3
0.0157
81
0.1460
10
Profit
without
hedging
(Cox-
Ross-
Rubinst
ein
model)
0.0149
80
0.6849
80
0.4549
80
0.1849
80
(-)0.27502
010
0.1749
80
(-)0.165
020
(-)0.115
020
(-)0.115
020
0.8349
80
1.6797
990
As can be seen from the figure, the total profit
brought by the hedging strategy using the implied
volatility calibrated by the Black-Scholes model from
June 2, 2022, to July 9, 2022, is $0.774094, the non-
hedging yield is $2.295039, which is higher than the
yield after hedging. The total income brought by the
hedging strategy using the implied volatility
calibrated by the Cox-Ross-Rubinstein model from
June 2, 2022, to July 9, 2022, is $0.146010, and the
non-hedging yield is $1.6797990, which is also
greater than the profits with hedging. In contrast, its
profit with hedging is lower than that of the hedging
strategy based on the implied volatility calibrated by
the Black-Scholes model.
3.2 Discussion
As for the results, hedging strategies constructed from
the implied volatility calibrated by the two models
performed well on the specific options of Unilever
PLC. This is reflected in the fact that both hedging
strategies keep the option return at a positive value,
and the return level is stable, a little higher than zero,
which means that the risk is well hedged. In order to
illustrate this point, first, volatility generally reflects
risk, and a relatively stable yield curve can better
reflect that risk has indeed been reduced. Second,
delta can also be understood in options calculation as
always, the probability of an option that can benefit or
lose. For instance, for an at-the-money option, the
delta value is generally around 50%. This is because
the stock price is equal to the strike price of the option
at a certain moment, and at the next moment, the stock
price is equal to the strike price of the option. It may
go up or down, and the probability of both is 50%. If
the stock price increases, then this at-the-money call
option becomes an in-the-money call option, and the
delta value will be higher than 50%. This option has a
greater than 50% probability of being exercised and
profiting. If the stock price decreases at the next
moment, this option will become an out-of-the-money
call option, and the delta value is less than 50%,
indicating that this option has a less than 50% chance
of being exercised and benefiting. The option selected
in this paper is an in-the-money call option with a
delta value higher than 50%, which implies that it has
a higher than 50% probability of being exercised and
benefiting on the expiration date. At the same time,
the object of this paper is Unilever PLC to represent
the FMCG industry. From July 2022 to August 2022,
the stock prices of most FMCG companies, including
Unilever PLC, have a slight upward trend. It can be
seen from the Unilever PLC stock price trend table in
the data section of this paper that when Unilever
PLC's share price rises, the delta value of the selected
in-the-money call option will inevitably rise, and the
possibility of profit is greater. When it is less than the
stock price at a certain moment, the possibility of
making a profit is also inevitable, which also shows
that the options profit without hedging increases and
is greater than the profits with hedging. The hedging
strategy made in this paper is to neutralize the delta
value and make it zero, which reduces the risk and
also inhibits the possibility of profiting by options.
Therefore, when the stock price is known to be rising
and the object of the hedging strategy is in the case of
in-the-money call options, it is inevitable that the
return after hedging is less than the return before
hedging, and the two hedging strategies with different
implied volatility make the level of the return curves
after hedging close to 0, indicating that they are well
achieved for the purpose of hedging delta.
In addition, it can be seen from the Results section
that the hedging strategies constructed by the implied