A Comparative Analysis of the Impact of Soviet Rule on the Cultural

Identity of Uzbekistan

Bobir A. Odilov

and Nodir R. Karimov

Tashkent State University of Oriental Studies, Uzbekistan

Keywords: Soviet Rule, Cultural Identity, Comparative Analysis, Cultural Landscape, Traditions, Art, and Architecture.

Abstract: This article discusses the impact of Soviet rule on the cultural identity of Uzbekistan: a comparative analysis.

The impact of Soviet rule on the cultural identity of Uzbekistan is a complex phenomenon that continues to

shape the country's cultural landscape. While the Soviet era brought certain challenges to the preservation of

the Uzbek language, traditions, art, and architecture, it also resulted in certain enduring legacies. The

comparative analysis of pre-Soviet and Soviet eras provides insight into the struggles faced by Uzbekistan in

maintaining its cultural identity and the ongoing efforts to reaffirm its heritage in the post-Soviet era.

Acknowledging and understanding these influences helps us appreciate the resilience and richness of

Uzbekistan’s cultural heritage and its ongoing evolution.

1 INTRODUCTION

The cultural identity of Uzbekistan has been shaped

by a complex history, with one significant influence

being the period of Soviet rule that spanned from the

early 1920s to the late 1990s. This article aims to

analyse the impact of Soviet rule on the cultural

identity of Uzbekistan through a comparative lens. By

examining key aspects such as language, education,

art, and architecture, we will explore both the

enduring legacies and the challenges faced by

Uzbekistan in maintaining its unique cultural identity

in the aftermath of Soviet rule.

Language plays a significant role in shaping and

preserving cultural heritage. In Uzbekistan, the

importance of the Uzbek language goes far beyond

serving as a means of communication. It serves as a

cultural lifeline, connecting generations to their

history, traditions, and values. In the following

paragraphs, we count the significance of language to

identity.

The Uzbek language has a rich history that spans

centuries and is rooted in the ancestral languages of

Turkic tribes in Central Asia [1]. Over time, it

evolved into the definitive language spoken by the

majority of the population in Uzbekistan. This

https://orcid.org/0000-0002-9961-3071

https://orcid.org/0000-0001-5127-8713

linguistic continuity is a testament to the resilience of

the Uzbek people and their commitment to preserving

their cultural heritage. These factors are considered as

historical significance.

Language acts as a vehicle for cultural expression,

and the Uzbek language is a cornerstone of Uzbek

cultural identity. It embodies the unique traditions,

customs, and values that have been passed down from

generation to generation. Through its vocabulary and

grammar, the Uzbek language carries the intangible

aspects of Uzbek identity, allowing individuals to

connect with their roots and heritage. It is cultural

identity.

The Uzbek language has fostered a rich tradition

of literature and art, showcasing the depth and

diversity of Uzbek culture. From classic works of

poetry and prose to contemporary novels and plays,

Uzbek literature has produced renowned authors who

have used the language to explore themes of love,

history, and societal issues [2]. Both indigenous and

foreign influences have shaped Uzbek art, with the

language serving as the medium for these

expressions.

Oral tradition has always played a crucial role in

preserving cultural heritage. In Uzbekistan, the

Uzbek language serves as the vessel for transmitting

and preserving traditional stories, legends, and

1250

Odilov, B. and Karimov, N.

A Comparative Analysis of the Impact of Soviet Rule on the Cultural Identity of Uzbekistan.

DOI: 10.5220/0012963300003882

Paper published under CC license (CC BY-NC-ND 4.0)

In Proceedings of the 2nd Pamir Transboundary Conference for Sustainable Societies (PAMIR-2 2023), pages 1250-1256

ISBN: 978-989-758-723-8

folklore. These tales, passed on through generations,

shape the collective memory of the Uzbek people,

instilling a sense of pride and connection to their

roots(Abaskanova., 2016- Khakimova., 2014).

2 DISCUSSIONS

During the period of Soviet rule, the promotion of the

Russian language posed a significant challenge to the

preservation of the Uzbek language and cultural

heritage. However, in post-Soviet Uzbekistan, there

has been a resurgence in the efforts to revitalize and

promote the Uzbek language. The recognition of its

importance in preserving cultural identity has led to

initiatives such as language education programs,

literature festivals, and cultural events that celebrate

the Uzbek language.

The Uzbek language is not merely a tool for

communication; it is a vital part of the cultural fabric

of Uzbekistan. It serves as a link to the past, a bridge

between generations, and a source of cultural pride.

Preserving and promoting the Uzbek language is

essential for safeguarding the unique heritage of

Uzbekistan and ensuring that future generations

continue to embrace their identity. By valuing and

supporting the Uzbek language, we uplift the diverse

cultural expressions it represents and provide a

foundation for the thriving cultural mosaic that

defines Uzbekistan.

Uzbekistan, with its rich cultural heritage and

historic significance, boasts a diverse linguistic

landscape. As a country situated at the crossroads of

Central Asia, Uzbekistan is home to numerous

languages, each contributing to the country’s vibrant

tapestry of cultures and traditions. And the following

paragraphs we count some languages which are used

in Uzbekistan.

The Uzbek language serves as the official

language of Uzbekistan, spoken by the majority of its

population. It belongs to the Turkic language family

and is closely related to other Turkic languages

spoken in the region. Uzbek holds great importance

in preserving the country's cultural identity and serves

as a means of communication throughout Uzbekistan.

Due to historical and social factors, the Russian

language holds significant influence in Uzbekistan. It

was the lingua franca during the Soviet era and

continues to have a strong presence today. Russian is

widely spoken by older generations and is particularly

prevalent in urban areas, government institutions, and

educational settings. It serves as a link to the country's

Soviet past and acts as a bridge between various

ethnic groups.

Tajik, an Indo-European language, is spoken by

the Tajik minority in Uzbekistan, primarily in the

Bukhara and Samarkand regions. Tajik is closely

related to Persian and is written in the Cyrillic script.

This language is deeply intertwined with the cultural

and historical heritage of the Tajik community,

serving as a symbol of their unique identity.

Karakalpak, an Oghuz Turkic language, is

spoken by the Karakalpak people inhabiting the

autonomous region of Karakalpakstan in Uzbekistan.

With its own distinct culture and history, the

Karakalpak language serves as a testament to the

linguistic diversity found within the country. Efforts

have been made to preserve and promote this

language, including the establishment of educational

institutions and support for cultural events.

Other Regional and Minority Languages. In

addition to the aforementioned languages, Uzbekistan

is home to a variety of other regional and minority

languages. These include Kazakh, Kyrgyz, Turkmen,

Korean, and various dialects spoken by smaller ethnic

communities. These languages are a reflection of the

multiculturalism and diversity that define Uzbekistan,

contributing to the cultural heritage and enriching the

linguistic landscape of the country.

The linguistic diversity found in Uzbekistan is a

testament to its multicultural history and vibrant

heritage. The coexistence of numerous languages

speaks to the country's capacity for cultural synthesis

and tolerance. Recognizing and celebrating this

linguistic mosaic is essential for promoting diversity,

inclusivity, and cultural understanding in Uzbek

society. By embracing and valuing the multitude of

languages spoken in Uzbekistan, we can fully

appreciate the richness of its cultural tapestry and

strengthen the bonds that unite its diverse

communities.

The linguistic landscape of Uzbekistan has been

shaped by historical, political, and social influences.

One such influence is the promotion of Russian as a

lingua franca, particularly during the Soviet era and

following paragraphs, we count these influences.

During the Soviet era, the Russian language was

actively promoted as the lingua franca across the

Soviet Union, including in Uzbekistan. Russian

became a prestigious language associated with

education, government institutions, and the elite. It

was taught in schools and universities, leading to a

significant number of Uzbeks becoming proficient in

Russian. And it is historical context.

There are two linguistic impacts and the

following we discuss them:

a. Bilingualism and Language Shift. The

promotion of Russian resulted in a significant number

A Comparative Analysis of the Impact of Soviet Rule on the Cultural Identity of Uzbekistan

1251

of Uzbeks becoming bilingual, and fluent in both

Uzbek and Russian. Many Uzbek families

encouraged their children to learn Russian to enhance

their career prospects and access higher education

opportunities. This bilingualism led to a gradual

language shift, with Russia gaining prominence in

certain domains of public life.

b. Influence on Vocabulary. The presence of

Russian as a prominent language has had an impact

on the vocabulary of Uzbek. Numerous loanwords

from Russia have been incorporated into Uzbek,

particularly in domains such as technology, science,

and administration. This borrowing of Russian

vocabulary enriches the lexicon of Uzbek but also

highlights the linguistic influence of Russian.

Russia continues to play a significant role in

government and administrative functions. It is used in

official documents, court proceedings, and various

bureaucratic processes. Proficiency in Russian is

often seen as a prerequisite for government positions,

further reinforcing its importance in these domains.

Russian is still taught in schools and universities

across Uzbekistan, alongside Uzbek and other

languages. It remains a popular choice among

students due to its perceived economic and academic

advantages. However, efforts have been made to

promote Uzbek language education, recognizing the

need to preserve and strengthen the national

language.

In recent years, there has been a renewed focus on

promoting Uzbek as the primary language of

communication and education. The government has

encouraged the use of Uzbek in official settings and

has implemented policies to enhance its status. This

shift aims to reaffirm Uzbekistan's cultural identity

and preserve the national language against the

backdrop of increasing globalization.

The promotion of Russian as a lingua franca

during the Soviet era has undoubtedly left an impact

on the linguistic landscape of Uzbekistan. While it

has contributed to linguistic diversity and facilitated

communication, it has also led to a gradual shift in

language usage and the borrowing of Russian

vocabulary. Efforts to promote Uzbek language

education and elevate its status demonstrate a

commitment to preserving cultural identity and

strengthening national languages. Striking a balance

between the linguistic heritage of Russian and the

national language of Uzbek is crucial in maintaining

cultural diversity and promoting inclusivity in

Uzbekistan.

Language and cultural identity are closely

intertwined, representing the essence of a

community’s history, traditions, and values.

Uzbekistan, a culturally diverse nation enriched with

a long-standing heritage, faces numerous challenges

in preserving its native language, Uzbek, and

safeguarding its cultural identity. In the following

paragraphs, we will examine some of the issues one

by one.

The first issue is Globalization and

Modernization. As globalization accelerates and

modernization influences societies worldwide,

traditional languages and cultural practices are

increasingly at risk of being overshadowed by

dominant global languages and homogenizing forces.

Uzbekistan, with its rich linguistic and cultural

diversity, struggles to strike a balance between

embracing modernity and preserving its indigenous

language and customs.

The second issue is Urbanization and Migration.

Rapid urbanization and internal migration play a

major role in diluting Uzbek language and cultural

identity. As people move to larger cities in search of

employment or better opportunities, they are often

exposed to different dialects or even switch to a

lingua franca, such as Russian or English, for

socioeconomic reasons. Consequently, this gradual

language shift might lead to the erosion of Uzbek's

linguistic and cultural roots.

Educational System is the fourth issue. The

educational system plays a crucial role in language

preservation, yet it poses challenges that hinder the

Uzbek language's vitality. In Uzbekistan, there is a

heavy reliance on Russian as the medium of

instruction in schools, leading to a decreased

emphasis on speaking and learning Uzbek.

Insufficient resources and policies focused on

promoting the Uzbek language perpetuate a cycle

where the younger generation becomes disconnected

from their cultural heritage.

Digital Media and Global Dominance can be the

fifth issue. The rise of digital media platforms and the

dominance of English-language content present

additional challenges to the preservation of the Uzbek

language and cultural identity. The allure of popular

Western media, paired with limited or inadequate

Uzbek content online, contributes to the adoption of

foreign cultural norms and languages, thereby

marginalizing native traditions and the Uzbek

language.

Changes in Lifestyle and Values can be the last

issue. The transformation of societal dynamics and

values can impact language usage and cultural

practices. With Uzbeks increasingly embracing

modern lifestyles, often influenced by Western

cultures, traditional values may face marginalization

and a decline in relevance. This shift not only affects

PAMIR-2 2023 - The Second Pamir Transboundary Conference for Sustainable Societies- | PAMIR

1252

the language spoken but also the cultural symbols and

practices associated with the Uzbek identity.

Despite the above problems, there are suitable

solutions for them. And we will consider them below.

Implement comprehensive language programs

that prioritize the Uzbek language from an early age,

both in schools and within the community, ensuring

its relevance and continuity.

Foster the creation of high-quality online content

in Uzbek, ranging from educational resources to

entertainment platforms, to promote the language and

encourage its use among the younger generation

Invest in cultural institutions such as museums,

theatres, and art galleries that showcase Uzbek

traditions, providing a platform for the community to

appreciate and preserve their cultural identity.

Promote community-led language projects,

workshops, and events that encourage Uzbeks to

actively participate in cultural programs,

strengthening their bond with the language and

identity.

Develop and implement policies that prioritize the

value of the Uzbek language and culture. Provide

financial assistance to organizations and initiatives

focused on preserving the language and cultural

heritage.

Uzbekistan, a country with a rich Islamic heritage,

has long valued traditional Islamic education as an

integral part of its society.

Traditional Islamic education in Uzbekistan can

be traced back centuries to the arrival of Islam in the

region. The country's medieval centres of learning,

such as Bukhara and Samarkand, were renowned for

their scholars and madrasas (Islamic schools). These

institutions played a pivotal role in disseminating

Islamic knowledge, nurturing scholars, and

preserving the Uzbek cultural and religious identity.

Traditional Islamic education in Uzbekistan

emphasizes a holistic approach that combines

religious and secular studies. The curriculum

typically includes Quran memorization, Islamic

jurisprudence, Arabic language, Islamic history, and

various other subjects. Students engage in a dynamic

learning environment, applying critical thinking,

analytical skills, and moral teachings based on

Islamic principles.

One of the significant advantages of traditional

Islamic education is its focus on moral and ethical

development. Through the teachings of the Quran and

the life examples of the Prophet Muhammad, students

are instilled with values such as compassion, honesty,

integrity, and social responsibility. This emphasis on

values helps shape individuals who contribute

positively to their families, communities, and society

at large.

Traditional Islamic education plays a vital role in

preserving and nurturing the cultural identity of the

Uzbek people. It serves as a medium through which

the Uzbek language, arts, literature, music, and

traditions are upheld. By incorporating Uzbek

cultural elements into the educational process,

students cultivate a deep appreciation for their

heritage and strengthen their sense of belonging.

Islamic educational institutions in Uzbekistan

serve as focal points for community engagement.

They function not only as centres of learning but also

as places for social gatherings, cultural events, and

religious ceremonies. These institutions create a

strong sense of community cohesion and provide

platforms for intergenerational exchange of

knowledge and experiences.

Traditional Islamic education promotes interfaith

dialogue, fostering an environment of religious

tolerance and understanding. Through the teachings

of Islam, students are encouraged to respect and

engage in constructive dialogue with people of

different faiths. This approach cultivates a society

characterized by mutual acceptance, harmony, and

peaceful coexistence.

Traditional Islamic education remains a

significant pillar of Uzbek society, contributing to the

preservation of the country's rich cultural heritage,

moral development, and social cohesion. By blending

religious teachings with secular knowledge, Islamic

educational institutions in Uzbekistan nurture

individuals who possess both academic excellence

and a strong ethical foundation. Embracing the values

of tolerance, compassion, and respect, traditional

Islamic education continues to play a pivotal role in

shaping the character of the Uzbek people and

fostering a harmonious society.

The era of Soviet rule in Uzbekistan, which lasted

from 1924 to 1991, had a profound impact on the

intellectual development of the country. Here are

some of its effects.

Under Soviet rule, Uzbekistan's education system

underwent significant changes aimed at aligning it

with the principles of Marxism-Leninism. The

curriculum was restructured to emphasize sciences,

engineering, and technical subjects, while social

sciences and humanities were often overshadowed.

The education system became centralized, with

standardized textbooks and syllabi enforced

throughout the country.

One of the positive aspects of the Soviet influence

on education in Uzbekistan was an emphasis on

promoting literacy and providing access to education

A Comparative Analysis of the Impact of Soviet Rule on the Cultural Identity of Uzbekistan

1253

for all. The Soviet regime greatly expanded the

number of schools and universities, leading to

increased educational opportunities for the Uzbek

population. This had a transformative effect on

society, empowering individuals and opening up new

avenues for intellectual growth.

While the Soviet regime emphasized education, it

also sought to suppress traditional Uzbek cultural and

religious practices. Uzbek literature, language, and

artistic expressions were often overshadowed by

Russian influences. The Uzbek language had to

coexist with Russian as an official language, and the

promotion of Uzbek cultural heritage faced

challenges under Soviet rule. This led to a dilution of

traditional cultural values and a decline in the use of

the Uzbek language.

Soviet influence in education extended beyond

curriculum restructuring. It sought to indoctrinate

young minds with Marxist-Leninist ideology,

promoting loyalty to the Soviet state and its political

system. Students were encouraged to adopt Soviet

values and perspectives, and critical thinking that

questioned or challenged the regime's ideology was

often discouraged. This ideological indoctrination

had a lasting impact on the intellectual development

of Uzbekistan, shaping the worldview of many

generations.

Although the Soviet ideology overshadowed

certain aspects of Uzbekistan's intellectual

development, it also contributed to scientific and

technological advancements. Investments were made

in research centres, technological infrastructure, and

scientific institutions. This led to advancements in

fields such as engineering, medicine, and agriculture,

providing Uzbekistan with a strong scientific

foundation that continues to influence the country's

development today.

With the collapse of the Soviet Union in 1991,

Uzbekistan embarked on a gradual transition away

from the Soviet ideology and curriculum. Efforts

have been made to revive and promote the Uzbek

language, literature, and cultural heritage. The

education system has undergone reforms to promote

critical thinking, creativity, and a more balanced

approach to subjects encompassing both sciences and

humanities. However, the legacy of Soviet influence

is still felt, as it shaped a generation of Uzbek

intellectuals and continues to influence certain

aspects of the country’s educational system.

In the following paragraphs, we will consider

some representatives of the literature.

Alisher Navoi was a prominent poet and writer of

the 15th century, also known as the “Father of Uzbek

Literature”. Through his works, Navoi elevated the

Chagatai language and laid the foundation for

classical Uzbek literature. His masterpiece,

“Khamsa”, consisting of five major poetic works,

celebrated love, mysticism, and wisdom, showcasing

his profound understanding of human emotions and

experiences.

Abdullah Qodiriy was a prolific writer of the early

20th century who played a significant role in

modernizing Uzbek literature. His notable works

include “O’tgan Kunlar” (Days Gone By), which

depicts the challenges faced by Uzbek society during

the turbulent years of the early 20th century.

Qodiriy’s literary contributions were influential in

shaping the development of contemporary Uzbek

literature.

Fitrat was a renowned writer, philosopher, and

social critic of the early 20th century. He was

instrumental in introducing modernist ideas to Uzbek

literature, advocating for social reforms, and

exposing the shortcomings of society in his works.

Fitrat’s writings dealt with pressing issues such as

education, women's rights, and the need for social

progress.

Ural Tansykbaev was a prominent painter and

artist who revolutionized the Uzbek art scene in the

mid-20th century. His works reflected a unique blend

of traditional Uzbek motifs and modern artistic

techniques. Through vibrant colours and striking

compositions, Tansykbaev captured the essence of

Uzbek culture, landscapes, and everyday life, earning

him international recognition.

Zulfiya was a renowned female poet and writer

who emerged in the mid-20th century, leaving a

lasting impact on Uzbek literature. Her works focused

on themes of love, nature, and human emotions.

Zulfiya’s poetry resonated with readers due to its

lyrical beauty and ability to evoke deep emotions.

Babur, the founder of the Mughal Empire and a

descendant of the Mongol conqueror Genghis Khan,

was also a talented poet and writer. Babur’s memoir,

“Baburnama”, provides valuable insights into the

socio-cultural landscape of 16th-century Central Asia

and India. His prose and poetry showcased his

profound understanding of human nature and the

complexities of ruling.

The diverse architectural landmarks scattered

across the country reflect the unique identity and

heritage of the Uzbek people.

Uzbekistan has been deeply influenced by Islamic

architecture, which is most evident in the

breathtaking mosques, madrasahs, and mausoleums

found throughout the country. These structures

feature intricate geometric patterns, calligraphy, and

delicate tilework, showcasing the religious devotion

PAMIR-2 2023 - The Second Pamir Transboundary Conference for Sustainable Societies- | PAMIR

1254

and artistic craftsmanship of the Uzbeks. The Islamic

architectural elements serve as a visual representation

of the strong Islamic faith practised by the Uzbek

people.

The Timurid dynasty, led by the renowned

conqueror Timur (Tamerlane), left a lasting

architectural legacy in Uzbekistan. Timurid style is

characterized by grandeur, elegance, and a

harmonious blend of Persian, Islamic, and Central

Asian influences. The iconic Registan Square in

Samarkand, with its three grand madrasahs, is a prime

example of Timurid architecture, captivating visitors

with its ornate facades, towering minarets, and

majestic courtyards.

The city of Bukhara is a treasure trove of

traditional architectural styles, with its old town

recognized as a UNESCO World Heritage Site. The

Bukhara style is marked by its compact and enclosed

structures, such as the Lyab-i Hauz complex and the

Ark Fortress. Ornamental brickwork, wooden

columns, and distinctive blue domes characterize

Bukhara's architecture, providing a glimpse into the

city's rich history and significance as a centre of trade

and scholarship along the Silk Road.

Khiva, another UNESCO World Heritage Site,

showcases a unique traditional architectural style

known as Khiva style. The walled city of Khiva

boasts well-preserved structures like the Kunya-Ark

Citadel and the Juma Mosque. Khiva style is

characterized by intricate ceramic tilework, arched

entrances, and towering minarets. The structures

within the city walls preserve the architectural

essence of a medieval Silk Road trading post, offering

visitors a step back in time.

In contrast to the traditional architectural styles

found in Samarkand, Bukhara, and Khiva, the capital

city of Tashkent underwent significant modernization

during the Soviet era. Tashkent's architecture

highlights the influence of Soviet modernism with its

wide boulevards, grand public buildings, and

apartment blocks. However, efforts have been made

to preserve traditional elements within the city, such

as the Kukeldash Madrasah and the Barak-Khan

Madrasah.

The traditional architectural styles in Uzbekistan

serve as a visual embodiment of the nation's cultural

identity. By preserving and showcasing these

architectural marvels, Uzbekistan honours its rich

heritage and showcases its unique blend of Islamic,

Persian, and Central Asian influences. These

structures not only captivate with their beauty but also

convey the story of Uzbekistan's history, faith, and

contributions to art and architecture. As travellers and

admirers explore the diverse architectural landmarks

in Uzbekistan, they gain a deeper appreciation for the

country’s cultural richness and the intrinsic link

between architecture and cultural identity

(Dadabaev., 2015- David., 2001)

3 CONCLUSION

The impact of Soviet rule on the cultural identity of

Uzbekistan is a complex phenomenon that continues

to shape the country's cultural landscape. While the

Soviet era brought certain challenges to the

preservation of the Uzbek language, traditions, art,

and architecture, it also resulted in certain enduring

legacies. The comparative analysis of pre-Soviet and

Soviet eras provides insight into the struggles faced

by Uzbekistan in maintaining its cultural identity and

the ongoing efforts to reaffirm its heritage in the post-

Soviet era. Acknowledging and understanding these

influences helps us appreciate the resilience and

richness of Uzbekistan’s cultural heritage and its

ongoing evolution.

The notable poets, writers, and artists of pre-

Soviet Uzbekistan left an indelible mark on the

country's cultural and literary heritage. Their

contributions to literature, poetry, and art continue to

inspire and shape the creative endeavours of

Uzbekistan today. By celebrating their works and

recognizing their influence, we ensure that their

legacies remain alive and vibrant, contributing to the

diverse and flourishing cultural scene of Uzbekistan.

Preserving the Uzbek language and cultural

identity is crucial for maintaining a distinct national

heritage. By recognizing the challenges posed by

globalization, urbanization, changes in the

educational system, digital media dominance, and

shifting values, Uzbekistan can take proactive steps

to safeguard its cultural heritage. Through the

collaborative efforts of its people, government, and

international support, Uzbekistan can navigate these

challenges and renew its commitment to preserving

its language and cultural identity for future

generations.

The influence of Soviet ideology and curriculum

on Uzbekistan's intellectual development cannot be

overlooked. While it brought about advancements in

education and fostered scientific progress, it also had

a destabilizing effect on traditional cultural values

and limited critical thinking.

As Uzbekistan continues to navigate its post-

Soviet transition, efforts to revive and promote the

country’s cultural heritage, ensure academic freedom,

A Comparative Analysis of the Impact of Soviet Rule on the Cultural Identity of Uzbekistan

1255

and encourage critical inquiry are crucial for building

a diverse, intellectually vibrant society.

REFERENCES

Abaskanova, Z. (2016). Russian minorities in the Post-

Soviet Space: A Comparative analysis of Kyrgyzstan

and Uzbekistan. Central European University.

Khakimova, E. (2014). Cultural policy in Central Asia:

Comparative analysis of legislations and public

policies.

Dadabaev, T. (2015). Identity and memory in post-Soviet

Central Asia: Uzbekistan's Soviet past. Routledge.

Askarov, M. (2019). An overview of categories of identity

in the late XIX–early XX centuries on the territory of

modern Uzbekistan. Вестник КазНУ. Серия

историческая, 95(4), 4-14.

Ismailova, J. (2021). Mirza Bukhari: The Journey From

Entrepreneurship to Collecting. International Journal

on Integrated Education, 4(11), 69-73.

Karimov, N., & Doniyorov, A. (2019). Conflicting Views

Regarding the Hadiths. IJITEE, 8(12).

Is’haqov, M., Alimova, R., & Karimov, N. (2019).

Contribution of Abu Isa Tirmidhi to the Science of

Hadith. IJITEE, ISSN, 2278-3075.

Khudoyberdiyevich, D. A., & Rakhmonqulovich, K. N.

(2020). The historical significance of "dastur ul-muluk"

("guide to the kings") by Khoja Samandar Termizi.

Journal of Critical Reviews, 7(6), 159-162.

Sayfullaev, D. B. (2020). Conceptual Basis of the Modern

West and East Diplomacy Study. J. Legal Ethical &

Regul. Issues, 23, 1.

Abdullaev, E. (2016). Uzbekistan: Between Traditionalism

and Westernization. In Central Asia at the End of the

Transition (pp. 267-294). Routledge.

Abdullaev, E. (2016). Uzbekistan: Between Traditionalism

and Westernization. In Central Asia at the End of the

Transition (pp. 267-294). Routledge.

Ismailova, J. K. (2016). Gandhian from the history of

Collections of the Cultural Heritage of Uzbekistan

Abroad. International Journal on Integrated Education,

3(8), 136-142.

Gafurov, B. Z. (2020). Analysis of the relationship of

medical terminology with segment phonostylistics of

the noun in Russian, Uzbek and English languages.

Theoretical & Applied Science, (1), 464-466.

Achilov, O. R. (2018). Comparative analysis of

foregrounding in English and Uzbek languages. Web of

Scholar, 5(4), 23-27.

David, A., & Dominique, A. (2001). Identity counts: The

Soviet legacy and the census in Uzbekistan.

PAMIR-2 2023 - The Second Pamir Transboundary Conference for Sustainable Societies- | PAMIR

1256