● Demonstrated evidence of decreased costs,
increased efficiency, and positive
outcomes to justify investment.
Need for Positive Impacts and Benefits:
● Emphasizing the benefits of using robotics
to increase resident engagement, reduce
workload, and facilitate hands-on care.
● Identifying potential positive impacts on
staff satisfaction, leading to enhanced
resident-staff interaction and care delivery.
4 DISCUSSION
Qualitative data reveals consistent optimism about
humanoid robots in nursing homes, acknowledging
their potential to enhance engagement, aid staff, and
improve residents' lives. However, concerns linger
around costs, the potential to replace human
interaction, and doubts about their full effectiveness
in caregiving. While administrators foresee workload
relief and improved resident engagement,
reservations exist about financial barriers, technical
challenges, and acceptance by staff and residents.
Despite recognizing their capabilities and supportive
infrastructure, worries persist about affordability and
regulatory barriers. Overall, these themes highlight
the necessity for thorough training, role clarification,
technology promotion, and effective integration to
ensure nursing home efficiency and satisfaction.
Usefulness: Analyzing the qualitative data on
administrators' perceptions of the usefulness of
humanoid robots in nursing homes reveals diverse
perspectives. Many administrators see potential in
robots for enhancing resident engagement,
entertainment, and physical activity, especially for
dementia residents. They highlight the robots'
potential to monitor falls, check on patients when
aides are busy, and improve patient care, while others
emphasize the robots' ability to augment human touch
and provide companionship. Concerns include
limitations in tasks, fear of resident misunderstanding
or breakage, and doubts about cost-effectiveness.
Some express skepticism about replacing human care
with robotics, emphasizing the need for human
interaction and concern over the potential fear or
confusion in advanced dementia patients. Overall,
there's recognition of the robots' potential to
supplement staff, engage residents, and improve the
quality of life in nursing homes, but reservations
persist regarding cost, human-like interaction, and the
ability to replace human care entirely.
Enhancing the Caregiving Abilities of Nursing
Homes: Analyzing the qualitative data on nursing
home administrators' perceptions of humanoid robots'
abilities to enhance caregiving reveals diverse
viewpoints. Administrators anticipate that these
robots could ease staff workload, free up time for
nurses, and engage residents more effectively. They
envision the robots learning patterns about residents,
assisting with non-human care-related tasks, and
leading activities while staff provides individualized
help. Many administrators believe these robots could
collect vital information, improve staff satisfaction,
and entertain both staff and residents. However,
concerns about staffing shortages, cost-effectiveness,
and limitations in the robot's capabilities remain
prominent. Some express doubts about the robots'
ability to replace human interaction or effectively
handle certain tasks, particularly in the absence of
advanced technology. Overall, there's recognition of
potential benefits in augmenting staff, engaging
residents, and improving efficiency, yet reservations
persist regarding the robots' cost, capability, and
potential impact on human interactions in caregiving.
Structural Barriers: Nursing home administrators
express varied apprehensions regarding the
implementation of humanoid robots. Chief among
their concerns are financial barriers, encompassing
high costs, budget constraints, and uncertainties
around funding. Technical challenges, such as
malfunctions, internet connectivity issues, and
compliance with regulations, also pose significant
hurdles. The physical environment presents its own
obstacles, including building structures, safety
considerations, and access through doors.
Administrator concerns extend to staff and resident
factors, involving training needs, resistance to
change, and uncertainties about resident acceptance.
Miscellaneous worries, like storage, beliefs regarding
surveillance, and specific technical glitches, further
compound the complexities of integrating robots into
nursing home settings. These multifaceted challenges
underscore the intricate nature of robot assimilation,
involving financial, technical, environmental, human,
and operational considerations.
Structural Support: The perceptions among nursing
home administrators highlight the pivotal role of
corporate backing and technological infrastructure,
emphasizing robust support from corporate entities
and an open-minded approach toward innovative
technology. They appreciate the benefits derived
from existing technology and Wi-Fi availability. The